Lab-Grown vs. Natural Diamonds: A Guide for Your Engagement Ring

Table of Contents

Introduction

When you’re looking for the perfect diamond, the choice between a lab-grown diamond and a natural diamond might seem confusing. However, it’s important to understand that both options are real loose diamonds with the same quality and characteristics. The key difference is how they are made: natural loose diamonds are formed deep inside the Earth over millions of years, while lab-grown loose diamonds are created in a laboratory in a matter of months.

Understanding Natural Diamonds

Natural loose diamonds are created deep within the Earth’s mantle, where extreme heat and pressure cause carbon atoms to bond and form crystals. This process takes billions of years, making natural loose diamonds incredibly rare and valuable. Over time, these diamonds are brought closer to the Earth’s surface through volcanic eruptions, where they can then be mined.

A Natural Diamond Fine Jewelry Piece

The mining process for natural loose diamonds involves extracting the stones from kimberlite pipes, which are deep, vertical geological structures that transport diamonds from the mantle. While some of the loose diamonds extracted are large and perfect, many are small or broken during the mining process.

Understanding Lab-Grown Diamonds

A lab-grown diamond is a real diamond created in a controlled lab environment using advanced technology. There are two main methods used to make these loose diamonds:

A Lab-grown Diamond Fine Jewelry

Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) and High-Pressure High Temperature (HPHT). Both methods mimic the natural process that forms diamonds in the Earth but on a much quicker timeline.

Lab-grown loose diamonds have the same physical and chemical properties as natural diamonds. This means they sparkle, shine, and are just as durable as diamonds mined from the Earth. They can even be graded using the same criteria—color, clarity, cut, and carat—by trusted certification bodies like the Gemological Institute of America (GIA).

Pros and Cons of Lab-Grown Loose Diamonds

Pros:

Cost-Effective: Lab-grown loose diamonds are typically 30-50% less expensive than natural loose diamonds of similar size and quality. This means you can buy a larger diamond for the same price or get a diamond of the same size for less money.
Ethical and Sustainable: Lab-grown loose diamonds do not require mining, so they are considered a more sustainable and ethical choice. There’s no risk of “conflict diamonds,” and they have a smaller environmental impact than mined loose diamonds.
Same Quality: Lab-grown loose diamonds are identical to natural loose diamonds in terms of their chemical composition, hardness, and appearance. You can get the same brilliant sparkle without the higher price tag.
Availability: HPHT and CVD methods help meet demand while maintaining quality

Cons:

Resale Value: While natural diamonds are rare and have a tendency to hold or even increase in value over time, lab-grown diamonds are mass-produced. This means they may not retain their value as well in the resale market.
Energy Use: Creating lab-grown diamonds requires energy, and some methods, like HPHT, consume a significant amount of power. However, advancements in technology are making the process more energy-efficient.

Are Lab-Grown Diamonds Real?

Yes, lab-grown diamonds are real loose diamonds. They are chemically identical to natural diamonds, meaning they are made of pure carbon that has crystallized into a diamond structure. Lab-grown diamonds can be cut, polished, and graded just like natural diamonds and even come with official certifications.

In fact, the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), one of the most respected names in diamond grading, has been certifying lab-grown diamonds since 2007. Since 2019, they have started issuing grading reports for these diamonds without using the term “synthetic,” as the stones are considered equal to natural diamonds in quality.

On average, lab-grown certified diamonds can cost up to 50% less than natural diamonds. For example, a 1-carat round diamond priced at £5,955 for a natural diamond might cost only £1,230 for a lab-grown equivalent, depending on its quality.

How Are Lab-Grown Diamonds Made?

There are two main methods to create lab-grown diamonds:

Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD): In this process, a tiny diamond seed is placed inside a chamber where carbon-rich gases are heated. These gases break down and bond to the seed crystal, layer by layer, forming a larger diamond.
High-Pressure High Temperature (HPHT): This method simulates the extreme conditions found deep in the Earth. It involves placing graphite in a machine where it is subjected to high heat and pressure, turning it into a diamond.

Both methods produce diamonds that are visually identical to natural diamonds. While the two processes are different, they both result in a high-quality stone.

The Differences Between Lab-Grown and Natural Diamonds?

When it comes to appearance, there is no difference between lab-grown and natural diamonds. Both types of diamonds have the same color, clarity, cut, and carat weight. Even experts may find it difficult to tell them apart without specialized equipment.

However, the main difference is how the diamonds are formed. Natural loose diamonds take millions of years to form under the Earth’s surface, while lab-grown diamonds can be created in just a few months. This difference in formation time doesn’t affect their quality or appearance, but it does mean lab-grown diamonds are more affordable.

Difference Table – Natural vs Labgrown Diamonds:

Feature	Natural Diamonds	Lab-Grown Diamonds
Creation Process	Formed naturally over billions of years under the Earth’s surface due to heat and pressure.	Created in a lab using methods like CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition) or HPHT (High Pressure High Temperature).
Material	Made from pure carbon that has been subjected to intense heat and pressure deep in the Earth.	Also made from pure carbon, with the same chemical composition as natural loose diamonds.
Price	More expensive due to the cost of mining, rarity, and limited supply.	Less expensive, often up to 50% cheaper due to lower production costs.
Value	Considered more valuable in terms of market value, but its worth is subjective.	Generally lower in value, but price may decrease over time as technology improves.
Durability	Extremely durable and hard, ranking 10 on the Mohs scale of hardness.	Also durable and hard, ranking 10 on the Mohs scale of hardness.
Clarity	Can have natural inclusions or flaws that affect clarity, and grading can vary.	May also have inclusions, with clarity graded similarly to natural loose diamonds.
Color	Natural loose diamonds can range in color from colorless to yellow or brown.	Lab-grown loose diamonds can also have a range of colors, with the same grading system as natural loose diamonds.
Environmental Impact	Mining has a significant environmental footprint due to the extraction process.	More eco-friendly in terms of production, but still requires energy to grow the loose diamonds.
Ethics	Some natural loose diamonds are mined under conditions that raise ethical concerns (e.g., conflict diamonds).	Lab-grown loose diamonds offer a clearer chain of custody, with less concern about ethical sourcing.

How to Choose Between a Lab-Grown Diamond and a Natural Diamond?

The decision between a lab-grown and natural diamond comes down to personal preferences and priorities. Here are a few factors to consider:

Budget: Lab-grown diamonds offer a more affordable option, allowing you to purchase a larger or higher-quality stone without exceeding your budget.
Ethical Concerns: If you’re concerned about the ethical implications of diamond mining, lab-grown diamonds are a great choice as they don’t contribute to the environmental or social issues associated with traditional diamond mining.
Resale Value: If you’re considering the potential future resale of your diamond, a natural diamond might hold more value over time because of its rarity. However, if resale value isn’t a major concern for you, a lab-grown diamond could be the better choice.
Appearance: If you want a diamond that looks the same as a mined diamond, a lab-grown diamond will meet your needs perfectly. They sparkle just as brightly, and unless you’re an expert, you likely won’t be able to tell the difference.
Finding a GIA Diamond: To find a GIA diamond, you can ask jewelers directly whether they offer GIA-graded diamonds. The GIA can grade both natural and lab-grown diamonds. Look for diamonds that have a GIA report number inscribed on them, which allows you to access the report online for verification easily. This transparency ensures that you’re buying a genuine and thoroughly tested stone.

Is it safe to buy diamonds online?

When considering purchasing loose diamonds online, there are important factors to weigh. Here’s a summary of key points to keep in mind:

Expert Assistance: Always seek guidance from a gemologist or trusted jeweler, especially when buying loose diamonds online. Their expertise can help you avoid mistakes that come from relying solely on grade reports.
The Importance of Cut: The cut of a diamond plays a critical role in its beauty. Online, you might find diamonds with identical grades but different visual appeal. Prioritize a diamond’s cut over its grade to ensure you select a stone that truly sparkles.
Video and Magnified Images: Online retailers often provide high-resolution, 360° videos of diamonds. These videos allow you to inspect clarity and sparkle in greater detail, providing more insight than a simple grade report.
Price Comparison: While online retailers often offer lower prices than physical stores, be cautious. Always focus on value, not just price. A seemingly good deal might hide imperfections or poor cuts that affect the diamond’s appearance.
Transparency and Trust: When buying a diamond online, ensure the retailer provides clear information, including certification and return policies, so you’re protected in case the diamond doesn’t meet expectations.

By focusing on these essential pointers and seeking expert help, you can confidently buy loose diamonds online.

Understanding a little about Diamond Simulants

It’s important to understand the difference between lab-grown diamonds and diamond simulants. Lab-grown diamonds are made from carbon, just like natural diamonds. On the other hand, diamond simulants look like diamonds but are not made from carbon crystals.

Two common diamond simulants are moissanite and cubic zirconia.

Moissanite: Natural moissanite is very rare and comes from space, found in meteorites. The moissanite available for purchase is lab-grown. While it can resemble a diamond, it tends to have more of a rainbow-like sparkle rather than the typical bright shine of a diamond.

Cubic Zirconia (CZ): CZ is another synthetic material often used as a substitute for diamonds. While it has some sparkle and is durable, it doesn’t shine as brightly as a diamond and may wear down over time. It is often used temporarily in jewelry until a more durable stone is chosen.

Colored Lab Grown Diamonds

In addition to colorless diamonds and simulants, lab-grown diamonds come in fancy colors, which are very rare in nature. These diamonds are made with small amounts of specific elements during their creation, just like naturally colored diamonds. They are more affordable than their natural counterparts.

Moissanite, cubic zirconia & Colored Lab Grown are not real diamonds, although they may look similar. They are priced much lower than lab-grown diamonds because they don’t have the same chemical and physical properties as real diamonds.

You can usually tell the difference between simulants and diamonds using a handheld diamond tester. Diamonds, whether natural or lab-grown, have distinct thermal properties that simulants do not. However, some lab-grown diamonds and certain naturally colored diamonds might appear similar to moissanite when tested with some diamond testers. Despite this, gemologists can easily tell the difference because moissanite is double-refractive, while diamonds are single-refractive.

Conclusion

Both lab-grown and natural diamonds have their merits, and the right choice for your Diamond Engagement Ring depends on your individual preferences and priorities. Whether you opt for a lab-grown diamond for its sustainability and affordability or a natural diamond for its rarity and investment potential, you can be sure that both options offer stunning, durable stones for your engagement ring or other fine jewelry pieces. By understanding the key differences and considering factors such as price, ethical concerns, and personal values, you can confidently make an informed decision when purchasing your diamond.

Choose the diamond that is right for you!

Grand Diamonds offers exquisite fine jewelry and luxurious diamond engagement rings, all crafted from high-quality materials like certified diamonds and 18k gold. Founded in 2014 by CEO Tetro Avi in Antwerp, the heart of the European Diamond Capital, Grand Diamonds ensures that each piece is a cherished investment.

Read more:

FAQs

Are Lab-Grown Diamonds More Ethical?

Lab-grown diamonds are often seen as a more ethical choice because they don’t involve mining. Traditional diamond mining can have a negative environmental impact, and there are concerns about labor conditions in some mines. Lab-grown diamonds avoid these issues since they are produced in controlled lab environments without the need for mining. However, it’s important to note that not all lab-grown loose diamonds are created equally. While the creation process is more environmentally friendly than mining, the methods used can still consume large amounts of energy, particularly the HPHT method. So, it’s important to consider the sustainability of the specific lab-grown diamond you’re purchasing.

Should You Get a Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement Ring?

Whether a lab-grown diamond is the right choice for your engagement ring depends on your personal preferences. A lab-grown diamond is a great option if you’re looking for a high-quality, ethical, and affordable diamond. They offer excellent value without compromising on quality or appearance. If you’re drawn to the rarity and tradition of a natural diamond, and you’re willing to pay a premium for that, then a natural diamond might be the better choice for you. Both options are beautiful and authentic, so it really comes down to what matters most to you.

Which type of diamond should I choose?

The choice between a lab-grown and a natural loose diamond is personal. If you value sustainability, ethical sourcing, and a lower price, lab-grown loose diamonds may be the best option for Engagement Ring Online. If you’re looking for a natural diamond with potential for investment or inheritance, a mined diamond might be a better fit.

Can I tell the difference between a lab-grown and a natural diamond?

It is nearly impossible for the average person to spot the difference between a lab-grown and a natural diamond. Professional jewelers use specialized equipment to identify the origin of the diamond, but to the naked eye, they are virtually identical.

Are synthetic diamonds real diamonds?

A common question that arises is whether it is accurate to call lab-grown loose diamonds “synthetic” diamonds. According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), lab-grown loose diamonds cannot be called synthetic because they share the same chemical composition as natural loose diamonds. Both natural and lab-grown diamonds are made of pure carbon and are considered real diamonds, despite their different origins.